Queering the Pilling Report: Church of England Reports and the 'Queer Art of Failure'
Cowell Doe, P
Date: 9 January 2023
Thesis or dissertation
Publisher
University of Exeter
Degree Title
PhD in Theology
Abstract
Pilling – The Report of the House of Bishops Working Group on Human Sexuality, published in November 2013, initiated a process within the institutional Church of England of discussions and reflections on the issue of (homo)sexuality. This thesis will que(e)ry the contents and methodology of this report, set in the context of earlier ...
Pilling – The Report of the House of Bishops Working Group on Human Sexuality, published in November 2013, initiated a process within the institutional Church of England of discussions and reflections on the issue of (homo)sexuality. This thesis will que(e)ry the contents and methodology of this report, set in the context of earlier church reports on sexuality, analysing the hermeneutical lenses through which Pilling chose to examine homosexuality and its place in church polity. After critically reflecting on the report itself, the thesis will turn to the processes which it launched: official and unofficial conversations about gay identity and gay relationships. Both the report and these processes will be interrogated for their constructions of authority and for their, perhaps unacknowledged, construals of power and privilege in which white, educated, cisheterosexual norms remain unmarked and ‘other’ identities are (albeit implicitly) positioned as abject. Pilling – both report and process – claims that it is not searching for a consensus or a resolution in the sexuality debate, yet its apparent reliance on the neoliberal narrative of progress and productivity denies the possibility of failure. The thesis suggests that one kind of resolution might be through, what Halberstam has termed, the ‘queer art of failure’, a turning away from the hegemonic epistemologies of church reports and institutionally sanctioned debate, towards an undoing of theological privilege and hierarchical constructions of authority. The queer art of failure recognises that failure is part of the human condition and for Christians an inherent part of our fallen nature. Failure may be faithfulness to an apophatic tradition, inhabiting the unknowingness of Holy Saturday and the queer temporality of living in the ‘not yet’.
Doctoral Theses
Doctoral College
Item views 0
Full item downloads 0
Related items
Showing items related by title, author, creator and subject.
-
The God of all the Earth: Contextual Theology in a Globalizing World The Example of Korea
Hwang, Namduk (University of Exeter Theology and Religion, 19 February 2013)Korea became a multicultural society through the influx of foreigners: migrant workers, international married couples, foreign students, and naturalized citizens. This social change challenges Korean churches to reflect ... -
An Examination of Prevalent Twenty-First Century Models of Community Engagement by the Black Churches
Bellamy, Brian Odem (University of Exeter Theology, 24 June 2016)An Examination of Prevalent Twenty-First Century Models of Community Engagement by the Black Churches Brian Odem Bellamy (ABSTRACT) This thesis examines three prevalent models of community engagement in the black ... -
Finding a Lutheran Theology of Religions: Ecclesial Traditions and Interfaith Dialogue
Mary Christine Lohr (University of Exeter Theology, 11 September 2009)The question of who is participating in today’s debate around theologies of other religions is important. Religious difference and the many ways of dealing with it are issues in political, social and theological initiatives. ...