Investigating Middle Stone Age foraging behaviour in the Karoo, South Africa

Abstract

The Middle Stone Age (MSA) in Africa ~500- 50 kyr is recognised as a key time-period associated with important developments in hominin evolution, including the appearance of earliest genetic markers for Homo sapiens. Despite advances, our knowledge of the behaviour of hominins during this period is limited, especially for the early MSA (EMSA) pre-160ka. This study presents new data on animal bones recovered at the Bundu Farm site, in the upper Karoo region of the Northern Cape, South Africa, dated to circa ~300ka and found in association with EMSA type lithic facies, burning and hearth-like features. Previous analysis of the Bundu fauna compared the site to a G/wi hunter-gatherer 'biltong' processing locale, implying primary access to animal carcasses and socially complex hunting behaviour, circa 400-300 ka. An interpretation at odds with other interpretations of the EMSA data that suggest limited hunting and social complexity, and which would therefore have significant implications for MSA archaeology. To test the biltong hypothesis my study presents new data on the fracture characteristics of non-fresh animal bone broken by hammerstone and new environmental data for the site from an analysis of ostrich eggshell isotopes. Experimental and environmental data are used to provide a new interpretation of the Bundu fauna and my conclusion is that the data while not supporting the biltong model, does indicate evidence of delayed communal food consumption, use of fire and the transformation of foodstuffs into meals presaging and echoing social and ecological adaptations seen in the later MSA and LSA. The data also highlights a greater role for carnivores in the accumulation of the faunal assemblage and expedient hominin foraging similar to the preceding ESA and brings attention to the ecological relationships between hominins and carnivores in a Pleistocene Karoo environment that was markedly different from that of today. The study therefore rejects the biltong hypothesis for Bundu Farm as both inconsistent with likely EMSA social structures and ecology and instead proposes the site as evidence for novel behaviour indicative of a transition from ESA to MSA lifeways. The Bundu Farm site reflecting a rare archaeological occurrence where the shift in the behavioural trajectory that led to our species is observed.