Wellbeing and Justice dimensions of Planned Relocation under Climate Change for Socially Marginalised Communities
Stefancu, O
Date: 19 December 2022
Thesis or dissertation
Publisher
University of Exeter
Degree Title
PhD in Human Geography
Abstract
This thesis examines the impact of government action and inaction in the context of climate change adaptation on people’s wellbeing and perceptions of fairness. Whilst it acknowledges the spectrum of government action and inaction for comparative purposes, the central focus of this thesis is on planned relocation. The thesis addresses ...
This thesis examines the impact of government action and inaction in the context of climate change adaptation on people’s wellbeing and perceptions of fairness. Whilst it acknowledges the spectrum of government action and inaction for comparative purposes, the central focus of this thesis is on planned relocation. The thesis addresses three well-identified knowledge gaps.
First, evaluations of planned relocation commonly focus on the risks and benefits of government intervention, often overlooking the consequences of not intervening. This study, therefore, accounts for uneven government action and inaction, looking across the range of outcomes by developing a categorisation of Planned Relocation, Adaptation In-Situ, and Lack of Adaptation. Second, planned relocation has traditionally been evaluated in terms of impacts on people’s income and livelihoods, human rights, or place attachments. This study presents a distinctive analysis of government action and inaction by assessing affected individuals’ wellbeing and perceptions of fairness. Wellbeing, as used here, is multidimensional, encompassing material, subjective, and relational dimensions. Perceptions of fairness, as used, here account for distributive and procedural dimensions. Third, there is limited evidence on how perceptions of fairness of outcomes and decision-making processes affect an individual’s sense of wellbeing. This study, therefore, investigates the relationships between distributive and procedural aspects of fairness and subjective wellbeing. Overall, this study contributes to the fields of environmental justice and climate change adaptation by shedding light on the complex impacts of government action and inaction on wellbeing and perceptions of fairness among socially marginalised communities.
This study examines government action and inaction in the Ganges-Brahmaputra Delta in India. It focuses on localities on Sagar Island that are facing coastal erosion and flooding and where local populations recognise the need for government intervention but where there have been uneven government responses. A combination of inductive and deductive approaches is used to identify theoretically valid yet locally relevant aspects of wellbeing and fairness. Data are derived from mixed methods, used both for the purpose of development and expansion. The data includes narrative interviews (n=14) that aim to identify valued aspects of wellbeing and fairness, as well as surveys (n=222) and semi-structured interviews (n=14) that aim to measure the wellbeing and perceptions of fairness in Relocated, Adapted In-Situ, and Non-Adapted sub-populations.
The results reveal that, on average, most Relocated respondents own agricultural land, which is a key factor in evaluations of material wellbeing among the three unevenly adapted sub-populations that traditionally relied on subsistence agriculture. Livelihoods reconstruction and diversification are central to self-assessments of material and subjective wellbeing, and perceptions of distributive fairness. Relocated respondents report the highest levels of subjective wellbeing across most life satisfaction dimensions and dual social attachments to the original and new settlement. The Relocated, Adapted In-Situ, and Non-Adapted respondents form their perceptions of fairness in relation to the distribution of beneficial and adverse outcomes, employing the criteria of equity, equality, and need inconsistently. Perceptions of procedural fairness vary, but overall expectations of government action are low. Perceptions of fairness have not been found to influence respondents’ subjective wellbeing.
This study resonates with previous studies on planned relocation that place the issue of livelihoods as a key factor for successful adaptation. It demonstrates that when planned relocation improves material circumstances, the outcomes of the intervention are accepted and perceived as legitimate. Outcome satisfaction is the main criterion influencing the formation of perceptions of fairness. Pessimistic expectations of government intent and capacity combined with greater-than-expected government action are found to positively influence perceptions of fairness even in the absence of a participatory approach. This finding is distinctive from many studies that place participatory decision-making processes as central to the formation of perceptions of fairness. Considering the growing demand for planned relocation in response to climate change, these findings contribute to a more comprehensive understanding of marginalised communities’ expectations of adaptation.
Doctoral Theses
Doctoral College
Item views 0
Full item downloads 0
Related items
Showing items related by title, author, creator and subject.
-
Exploring the Concept of Individual Workplace Well-Being: What does it mean to have Workplace Well-being and What is the Role of Identity-Related Resources in Achieving it?
Rook, Caroline (University of Exeter University of Exeter Business School, Centre for Leadership Studies, 31 July 2013)When exploring workplace phenomena such as well-being, it is important to recognise the context in which the experience takes place. For example, many contemporary jobs require people to interact with others or to work in ... -
Natural environments and subjective wellbeing: Different types of exposure are associated with different aspects of wellbeing.
White, MP; Pahl, S; Wheeler, BW; et al. (Elsevier, 17 March 2017)Despite growing interest in the relationships between natural environments and subjective wellbeing (SWB), previous studies have various methodological and theoretical limitations. Focusing on urban/peri-urban residents ... -
Is teachers’ mental health and wellbeing associated with students’ mental health and wellbeing? A cross sectional study
Harding, S; Morris, R; Gunnell, D; et al. (Elsevier for International Society for Affective Disorders, 17 August 2018)Background: Factors within the school environment may impact young people’s mental health and wellbeing. The aim of this study was to understand the association between teacher and student mental health and wellbeing. ...