Who dares does not always win: risk-averse rockpool prawns are better at controlling a limited food resource
Maskrey, D; White, S; Wilson, A; et al.Houslay, T
Date: 28 May 2018
Journal
Animal Behaviour
Publisher
Elsevier Masson
Publisher DOI
Abstract
Animal ‘personality’ – the phenomenon of consistent individual differences in behaviour within
populations – has been documented widely, yet its functional significance and the reasons for its
persistence remain unclear. One possibility is that among-individual behavioural variation is linked to
fitness-determining traits via effects ...
Animal ‘personality’ – the phenomenon of consistent individual differences in behaviour within
populations – has been documented widely, yet its functional significance and the reasons for its
persistence remain unclear. One possibility is that among-individual behavioural variation is linked to
fitness-determining traits via effects on resource acquisition. In this study, we test this idea, using
rockpool prawns (Palaemon elegans) to test for a correlation between ‘high-risk exploration’ and the
ability to monopolise a limited resource. Modified open field trials (OFTs) confirmed that consistent
among-individual (co)variation in high-risk exploratory behaviours does exist in this species, and
multivariate analysis shows trait variation is consistent with a major axis of personality variation.
Subsequent feeding trials in size-matched groups where competition was possible revealed a high
repeatability of feeding duration, used here as a proxy for RHP (resource holding potential). We
found significant negative correlations between feeding duration and two ‘risky’ behaviours, such
that individuals that took fewer risks fed more. Our results are not consistent with the widely
hypothesised idea of a ‘proactive syndrome’ in which bolder, risk-taking personalities are positively
associated with RHP. Rather they suggest the possibility of a trade-off, with some individuals
successful at monopolising limited, high-value resources, while others are more willing to engage in
potentially risky exploration (which may increase the likelihood of encountering novel resource
patches). We speculate that alternative strategies for acquiring limited resources might thereby
contribute to the maintenance of personality variation observed in wild populations
Biosciences - old structure
Collections of Former Colleges
Item views 0
Full item downloads 0