Melton Mowbray to Middleburg: Transatlantic Dialogues in Fashionable Fox-hunting, 1870-1930
Clark, H
Date: 2 July 2018
Publisher
University of Exeter
Degree Title
PhD in History
Abstract
This study examines the role of fox-hunting in the establishment of Anglo-American elite transatlantic society between 1870-1930, and argues for a new appraisal of fox-hunting and its relevance to the study of Anglo-American elite history. Beginning with a focus on fox-hunting in the sporting capitals of Melton Mowbray, Leicestershire, ...
This study examines the role of fox-hunting in the establishment of Anglo-American elite transatlantic society between 1870-1930, and argues for a new appraisal of fox-hunting and its relevance to the study of Anglo-American elite history. Beginning with a focus on fox-hunting in the sporting capitals of Melton Mowbray, Leicestershire, England, and Middleburg, Virginia, USA, it demonstrates the ways in which hunting culture can be used to understand how rapid change (economic, social and cultural) was assimilated and realised by both the established and newly emerging elites on both sides of the Atlantic. Despite the very different circumstances in the two nations – one as an emerging ‘superpower’, the other a gradually declining Empire - it explores how fox-hunting functioned not just as a leisure pastime, but as an associational structure and vehicle for elite social intercourse, confirmation of social status and as a representation of national upper-class cultural and social capital, particularly as a transatlantic social season emerged. By breaking down thematic boundaries, this study demonstrates through its comparative, trans-national approach that fox-hunting was not a marginalised, isolated sporting activity, but one that was integral to elite production, consumption and sociability in two advanced industrial societies. It argues that the sport responded to and was the construct of the cultural, political and economic needs and societal aspirations of emergent metropolitan elites. This thesis also offers a new perspective on late nineteenth and early twentieth-century transatlantic history, in particular the role of hunting culture in facilitating international elite assimilation. Through an exploration of the cultural linkages and synergies that endured between the US and UK, it moves away from the familiar interpretative paths which focus on identifying difference between the British Empire and US Exceptionalism. It demonstrates that the study of fox-hunting can serve as a lens through which to compare the ways in which two societies undergoing extensive, profound and permanent economic, social and cultural change adopted and re-fashioned a traditional ‘elite’ pursuit to support ideas of legacy, tradition, national identity and history. Moreover, this research makes a significant contribution to our understanding of wider Anglo-American relations and the processes of cultural appropriation and re-invention amongst these elites. It demonstrates that the study of fox-hunting should be taken more seriously as it provides a valuable window into the operation of much broader elite social processes. Within US history, it also reinstates the importance of the sport in comparison to other forms of hunting. Most importantly for the study of Anglo-American relations and international elites, it reveals the different stages of cultural appropriation and how elite signifiers were not just appropriated or adapted in the US, but also underwent a process of re-invention that contributed to the growth of a distinctive American identity.
Doctoral Theses
Doctoral College
Item views 0
Full item downloads 0
Related items
Showing items related by title, author, creator and subject.
-
Persistence of Difference: a History of Cornish Wrestling
Tripp, Michael (University of Exeter Institue of Cornish Stuies, 30 May 2010)The aim of this study was to provide an historical analysis of Cornish wrestling and in particular to address the following key questions: How has Cornish wrestling developed as a sport? Why is Cornish wrestling ‘different’? ... -
Legalising and Enforcing Socio-Religious Norms: The State, Caste and Positions of Women in the Maratha Empire, 1674-1818
Prashant (University of Exeter Faculty of Humanities, Arts and Social Sciences (History), 11 April 2023)This thesis investigates the working of laws and judicial mechanisms, including religious and caste assemblies, in order to uncover impacts of the Maratha state’s religious and political ideologies and ambitions on the ... -
‘I tremble lest my powers of thought are not what they ought to be’: Reputation and the masculine anxieties of an eighteenth–century statesman
French, Henry (Palgrave Macmillan, 3 February 2018)This paper explores how masculine norms were rendered consequential through the practices of historical actors and institutions. It does so by focusing on changing perceptions of the masculine ‘character’ of the Georgian ...