Regulatory Impact Assessment: A Panacea to Over-Regulation?

DSpace/Manakin Repository

Open Research Exeter (ORE)

Regulatory Impact Assessment: A Panacea to Over-Regulation?

Please use this identifier to cite or link to this item:


Title: Regulatory Impact Assessment: A Panacea to Over-Regulation?
Author: Dunlop, Claire A
Citation: Dunlop, C.A. (2011) 'Regulatory Impact Assessment: A Panacea to Over-Regulation?', Journal of Risk Research, vol. 14, 8: 947-950.
Publisher: Taylor & Francis
Journal: Journal of Risk Research
Date Issued: 2011
Abstract: Donald MacRae offers a welcome and succinct intervention from an experienced regulation practitioner. MacRae argues convincingly of the perils of unchecked standard setting in the name of safety – the well known twin ills of additional burdens on industry and constraints on individuals’ liberty. While over-regulation in the name of safety may perhaps fairly be seen as Perrowian ‘normal accident’ of administrators’ encounters with uncertainty, MacRae rightly notes the unresolved and thorny questions about the legitimacy and accountability of those who ‘increase the safety ratchet’ whatever their motivation. Who are qualified to exercise these judgements? How do we ensure they can be held responsible for their actions (or inactions)? Recognition of this risk of setting the wrong standards has triggered two responses from within the standard setting community – specifically the work of UNECE WP.6 and INMETRO in Brazil. This commentary ponders what these nascent responses themselves imply for legitimacy and accountability and whether regulatory impact assessment offers a panacea to over-regulation.
Type: Other
Description: Commentary
Keywords: risk assessmentstandard settingregulatory impact assessment
Funders/Sponsor: European Research Council, grant no 230267 on Analysis of Learning in Regulatory Governance, ALREG.

Please note: Before reusing this item please check the rights under which it has been made available. Some items are restricted to non-commercial use. Please cite the published version where applicable.

Files in this item

Files Size Format View
Dunlop - MacRae Commentary.pdf 107.0Kb PDF View/Open

This item appears in the following Collection(s)


My Account

Local Links