Beyond powering and puzzling: the political dimensions of policy learning

Abstract

Over the years, policy learning has emerged as a theoretical lens to provide an alternative understanding to powering-based approaches to the policy process and policy outcomes. This has been a success story, with policy learning gaining presence among theoretical frameworks on the policy process. However, the puzzling-powering dichotomy is reductive. In real-world policy processes, we find both puzzling and powering. Also, we cannot reduce the value of learning to what is not explained by power alone. This Introduction shows how puzzling and powering interact and with what consequences on policy processes, moving beyond the dichotomy. We present how the four contributions of this Special Issue explore this territory, and suggest how to approach the design of governance architectures for learning.